Cooper Debate Team Member Portal
About Awards News Guides Events Gallery
EvidenceFind credible evidence
ArgumentsBuild both sides of the case
SourcesReliable & authoritative research
Case BuildingOrganize and develop your case
Research Hub →(Member Login)

PF Topic Center

Active PF Resolution — Sept/Oct 2026

"Resolved: The United States federal government should enact a moratorium on hyperscale data center construction."

7-slide student guide

September Tournament Topic Analysis

A concise introduction to hyperscale data centers, what a construction moratorium means, and the strongest arguments available to both sides.

✓ Pro Arguments
+A pause could protect communities from rising electricity bills and heavy water use
+Temporary limits could reduce pollution and pressure on the electric grid
+A moratorium could prevent wasteful overbuilding while stronger protections are developed
+Communities would gain more control over the local effects of large technology projects
✗ Con Arguments
Data-center projects can finance clean-energy production and grid upgrades
A broad pause could slow AI research, scientific computing, and job creation
Projects may move overseas, reducing U.S. investment and control
Targeted regulation could address harms without stopping construction nationwide

💡 Full evidence files, briefs, and flows available in the Members Portal Members Portal →

Key Research Sources

NSDA Topic Guide

The official NSDA Public Forum topic analysis including definitions, background, and key stakeholders for the current resolution.

Visit NSDA →
Government Sources

CISA, DNI, DOD, and Congressional Research Service reports on AI in national security — the gold standard for pro evidence.

CRS Reports →
Academic Journals

Peer-reviewed research on AI ethics, surveillance, civil liberties, and international security from major universities.

Google Scholar →

Debate Skills

Case Writing

A strong 4-minute constructive has 2–3 contentions, each with a clear claim, warrant, and impact. Lead with your strongest argument and pre-empt top counterarguments.

"Make your tag line a thesis statement, not a label."
Crossfire

Use crossfire strategically: ask short, closed questions to expose contradictions. Never answer a question you haven't thought through. Control pace — don't let your opponent run the clock.

"Ask questions, don't make speeches."
Summary & Final Focus

In summary, extend 2–3 key issues with offense. Respond to the most damaging attacks. In Final Focus, crystalize 1–2 voting issues and explain why you win them.

"Tell the judge what to weigh and why your evidence is better."
Impact Calculus

Compare arguments using magnitude (how big), probability (how likely), and timeframe (how soon). A clear calculus framing wins close rounds.

"Don't just win an argument — tell the judge why it matters MORE than theirs."
Delivery

Speak conversationally in PF — judges want to understand you, not be impressed by speed. Eye contact, vocal variation, and clear signposting make you a more persuasive speaker.

"If the judge can't follow you, you're losing."

How We Train

Timed Practice Rounds

We run full practice rounds weekly to build comfort with PF timing. Timers always running — no exceptions.

Flow Practice

Flowing is a critical skill. We practice flowing pre-written speeches until every debater can flow at full speaking speed.

Video Review

We record and review practice rounds to identify speech habits, argument gaps, and crossfire patterns to improve.

Templates & Flows

PF Case Template
Blank constructive template with contention headers, evidence blocks, and tag lines pre-formatted.
Flow Sheet (PF Format)
4-column flow sheet formatted for PF: Constructive / Rebuttal / Summary / Final Focus.
Evidence Card Template
Properly formatted evidence cards with source citation, date, tag line, and highlighted text fields.
Research Tracker
Spreadsheet for organizing sources by argument, side, and strength rating as you build your case.
Impact Calculus Framework
A one-page guide for comparing impacts across magnitude, probability, timeframe, and reversibility.

Full template library available to members. Log In to Access →

Cooper Debate · September 2026

September Tournament Topic Analysis

Take a quick look through the presentation, or open the original PDF for the full experience.

Topic Analysis title slide by Jacob Gibbons
Slide 1 of 7 Topic Analysis

Use the arrow keys to move through the deck · Press Esc to close